Talk:Skyrails

I just want to point out this is a really bad thing for the community on the MRT and I personally feel as if it will cause friction between players. - mine_man_

Having an open review platform like this may actually decrease frictions as opinions are listed and can be used to make improvements while at the same time moderated to an extent not to be personal attacks. Just a bus on the line 22 near you! (talk) 07:04, 21 December 2016 (EST)

Based on some of the reviews I completely disagree with some of these not being personal attacks - mine_man_

There is still a very large difference in having a negative opinion that doesn't have to match up with most other people and personally attacking and/or herrassing people. Just a bus on the line 22 near you! (talk) 07:17, 21 December 2016 (EST)

The review Ben provided.. is like "I went there for 2 minutes, and everything is so dang bad. Ima rate this 2/10. Hmm This airport? The owner of this airport was very nice to me, lemme give it a 10/10." While I do support the idea of a very open platform for players to comment on airports, some people should be banned.VernCow (talk) 07:37, 21 December 2016 (EST)

You know, it is petty arguments/community divisions such as these that make Frumple less willing to come on the server or to renew it in the future. Camelfantasy (M e h) 08:18, 21 December 2016 (EST)

but in the same way problems like this that create divisions in the community do the same thing.--Ptld | "That is our Comment, We welcome Yours." ~Fred Nutter (talk) 08:22, 21 December 2016 (EST)

I do not feel like it is right to remove independant reviews. - Troll or biased reviews happen in real life too - So what? In moderating these reviews you create another window for bias so essential you move the issue down the line. This page and system isn't set up very well (which makes it unclear and makes these biased reviews extra easy to do) but in a slightly different set up this shouldn't give any issues and could actually be used to get more and more indirect feedback on airports. There is no issue in this but ask airports to sign up for the project - Not list all airports. Critiquing airports or people without their consent is not apreciated generally. For me the conclusion is: the concept is great, the execution isn't; creating issues and possible devisions and rude/biased reviews in overload instead of a fair review system. Still, people mention ben's review of ATC. I like Kastle_'s airports in general but I am not a great fan of ATC either. I feel like this bias goes 2 ways. Just a bus on the line 22 near you! (talk) 09:10, 21 December 2016 (EST)

Ye.. but lemme quote yoshi here.. Minecraft is NOT real life...VernCow (talk) 09:17, 21 December 2016 (EST)

Do refer to Rule 1: Be kind and respectful to other players.